Tao Colorist Newsletter #377: The Resolution Myth Edition

Published: Sun, 10/14/18

Issue #377: The Resolution Myth Edtion
The Tao of Color Grading Newsletter
Curated links of news, reviews, thoughts, career advice, and humor
for professional Video / Film Colorists & Finishers. Delivered Sunday.
----
View in Browser | Web Archives
No. I'm not asking you to solve a math problem. Rather, I'm talking about photosite resolution on camera sensors. And how much more valuable are an additional 4K, when you already have 4K, 5K, or more K on todays digital cinema cameras?

I stumbled on this question (and the answer) while browsing the Facebook feed of colorist Scott Stacy CSI. He's the newest contributor to Mixing Light and after linking to his name in a Facebook post - I perused his Public feed.

I ran across an article he linked to featuring DP Steve Yeldin ASC. It was based on a series of camera tests showing that additional photosites don't increase the audience's sense of image quality (or Presence, a notion I'm starting to adopt from BBC white papers). Instead, Steve posits that the image pipeline has far more impact on the quality of our final images.

I'm writing about this here, in this week's introduction because I think it's an extremely important topic. And if you missed the article and Steve's two videos when released last year, then you need to take the time and absorb them.

This week, I'm linking to the ASC article discussing his videos. And I'm linking to Part 1. I encourage you to read and watch. Then marinate on Part 1 for a week - before watching Part 2, when I link to it next week.

See you next Sunday.

Happy Grading!

- Patrick Inhofer
Colorist | Publisher | Mentor
The Craft
Featuring the work of creative craftsmen, the theory of color, and industry news. Learn practical workflows, useful theories, and actionable insights from existing (and emerging) leaders and teachers in our industry.

Steve Yeldin, ASC talks about the K-effect and why greater pixel counts is a poor barometer of perceptual image quality.

[video] In this first video, DP Steve Yedlen ASC posits his hypothesis that pixel counts are not where we need to focus our attention for maximum perceived image quality. Where should we focus our efforts? Watch to find out. You won't be disappointed. And then think on this for a week. Next week I'll share the link for Part 2 where theory gets put to the test.
What are the people seeing each weekend, broken by specific demographics (from 18 - 50+)? An interesting article on what this new website is trying to achieve. My only problem? According to Movio your Gen X'er Newsletter Publisher has been age'd out of his own generation. I guess when you pass 50, the only demo you're part of is: old.
Sponsor
LumaForge + Resolve = Collaboration
We've spent the last 3 years designing a killer little shared storage device for color, editorial, and VFX workflows: we call it the Jellyfish. With an integrated database server, it's perfect for Resolve's groundbreaking Collaborative Workflow.
 
Jellyfish Shared Storage Systems start at $7,500.
 
CLICK to LEARN MORE about the Jellyfish at Lumaforge.com
The Tools
Our craft keeps changing. And growing. Learn about updates to your favorite software. Discover new tools to help you work faster or more creatively. Build your toolchest with new techniques and approaches.

This is a good explanation of using the Sharpen / Coring controls to fine tune your sharpening operations. Good explanation for Resolve users.

I'm glad I didn't skip NFS this week... as they had a good write-up of Baselight Editions V5 and how one editor put it through its paces on a recent series they delivered. Good factoids in here show that Editions and Avid are evolving well together.
The meta-description for this blog post says it best, "Has colorist Denver Riddle really revolutionised colour grading with this new plugin - Cinema Grade? I take a look at what all the fuss is about, offer 10% discount on cinema grade, provide a free keyboard shortcut cheat sheet, and chat to Denver Riddle about creating a brand new app from scratch."
[video] A nifty (and pithy) demo of how to, essentially, set up Colorista as a replacement to the Lumetri panel.
For you mavericks out there.
This item was written by Pomfort to promote their offloading software. But if you're new to the craft of DIT and need to understand the importance of generating logs of your backups, this is a great place to start learning.
Sponsor
FilmConvert.com
Professional film emulation and film grain for all of your projects

Speed up your grading and camera-matching tasks with the power of FilmConvert: 19 film stocks, 6K grain scans and dedicated camera profiles for the leading cameras on the market.

For fast turnaround and quick, cinematic results in just a few clicks. Plugin or Standalone.
Click to Save 10% off FilmConvert with promo code 'TAO'
Pushing Photons
These stories are from MixingLight.com's membership Library. It's a color grading website (Tao Of Color is co-Owner). Do you want to read a story listed here but not a member? Sign up for a free 7-Day Test Drive.​​​ There's also a free Resolve Course and color correction Practice Projects.
[video] While creating a 'Western' look, Contributor Scott Stacy CSI teaches how to use a color space transform with a film print emulation LUT in DaVinci Resolve. Free, in front of the paywall.
[videos] Colorist Dan Moran shares his thoughts (and embeds the videos) on the UKMVA Nominations 2018 for Best Grading. This year, Dan was also part of the judging panel.

In part 3 of the (free) ongoing Dolby Vision series, learn about big changes to Dolby Vision & Resolve in 2018, with new tools & workflows.

Sponsor
Flanders Scientific XM310K True 4K HDR Reference Monitor
The 31” XM310K is a true 4K resolution HDR reference monitor that qualifies as a Dolby Vision mastering monitor. With a peak luminance of 3,000nits it is the brightest commercially available professional HDR monitor on the market.
 
LEARN MORE About the FSI XM310K 4K HDR Reference Monitor
The Gear
Stay updated on the latest hardware that's shipping - because the craft of color grading isn't just about software. Plus, keep an eye on future equipment trends and camera odds-and-ends.
Tao Newsletter sponsor Lumaforge has a nice write-up describing one production's experience with the mobile Jellyfish SAN. It's a terrific solution you should understand if you need teams of creatives working simultaneously with shared media.
This review took place at Samsung's facility. But it's a good write-up of what seems to be an albatross... an 8K tv in a sea of HD and UHD content. I'm including this for the discussion of it's AI functionality (where it 'phones home' to update reference images to help with upscaling). Plus, it's a look at the brightness levels of next-gen LCDs and how they're back to competing with OLED for overall image quality & 'presence'.
Good review. My favorite bit comes in the Calibration section, "There are a wealth of picture modes to choose from . . . [that] are basically various degrees of wrong that differ based on how aggressive the picture enhancement systems are." Word. The built-in bias light is a terrific idea but by default seems executed in the form of gaming LEDs on GPUs rather than providing a whitepoint-tuned neutral field to anchor the image and relax the eyes.

Intels Core i9s get refreshed. More cores, greater efficiency, higher price. I like how Intel has categorized the three ranges of board designs: Low Core Count (LCC), Hight Core Count (HCC), and Extreme Core Count (XCC). Click through for the core'y details.

In a recent Newsletter I mentioned how the IMAX brand strategy for the past decade has eluded me. With this announcement I'm seeing their latest approach: Compete with Dolby Vision via HDR 10+. I wonder if we'll ever see their toolset integrated into DaVinci Resolve Studio? Is this a start of a new Betamax - Betacam war? Click through to understand what 'IMAX Enhanced' actually means.
Sunday Fun(nies)
Random thoughts, tidbits, and fun stuff that caught my attention this week. Maybe it's color grading related. Maybe not. Ya got'ta read to the end of the Newsletter to find out.
[video] Do you think the most interesting part of watching the engines ignite of a Saturn V launch are the flames? This video's narration make plain that that is only one part of the show. As my favorite alien says: Fascinating. Oh, and this particular launch? Apollo 11.
Yup. Get free compute time on a real quantum computer. Of course, just like on any giant mainframe your access is measured in... one minute. What?? Click through. It's fun, if you've got the heart of a geek.
 
Th- th- th- that's all folks! See you next Sunday!